Home / Insights / Business Growth

Business Growth

ADA Website Compliance in Florida: What to Fix First

If you run a small business in Florida, you have probably heard a story about a neighbor getting a demand letter over their website. This is a guide to ADA website compliance in Florida in plain English: how common these suits are, what a site is actually checked against, and what to fix first. It is not legal advice, and nothing here promises that any site is compliant or protected from a lawsuit. For legal questions, talk to an attorney.

How common are website accessibility lawsuits in Florida?

Common enough to take seriously. Seyfarth Shaw’s ADA Title III tracker counted 3,117 federal website accessibility lawsuits in 2025, and 961 of them were filed in Florida, almost double the 470 filed in 2024. New York was the only state with more. Those numbers cover federal court only; state-court filings are not included, and different trackers count slightly differently. Source: Seyfarth Shaw, ADA Title III blog (March 2026).

We have no data on how many of those targets were small businesses, so we will not guess. What the numbers do say is that Florida is one of the two busiest places in the country for these claims.

What ADA website compliance in Florida means in practice: WCAG 2.1 AA

There is no single law that lists website rules for private businesses. In practice, demand letters and settlements point to the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG), usually version 2.1 at level AA, published by the W3C. In plain English, the parts that trip up small-business sites most often are:

  • Alt text. WCAG asks for text alternatives for non-text content. A screen reader user hears a short description of your product photo or logo instead of silence or “image123.jpg”.
  • Keyboard navigation. Every menu, button and form must work without a mouse. Try it yourself: press Tab through your homepage and see whether you can reach and use everything, and whether you can see where you are.
  • Color contrast. Normal text needs a contrast ratio of at least 4.5:1 against its background (3:1 for large text). Light gray text on white is the classic failure.
  • Form labels. Each field in your contact or checkout form needs a real label tied to it, not just placeholder text that vanishes when you type.

The full list is longer, and conformance involves judgment calls that no checklist of four items captures. But these four are where we would start. Source: W3C, WCAG 2.1.

Why an overlay widget alone is not a fix

You have seen the ads: add one line of code and a little accessibility icon appears on your site. Overlays are cheap and quick, which is exactly why they are tempting. The evidence against treating them as a fix is strong at the regulatory level. In 2025 the U.S. Federal Trade Commission finalized an order against the overlay vendor accessiBe, requiring a $1 million payment and barring it from claiming its automated tools can make a website WCAG-compliant unless it has evidence to back that up. The FTC’s complaint alleged the product did not in fact make all sites compliant. Source: FTC press release, April 2025.

That order binds one company, so it is not a ruling on every overlay. Still, the underlying problem is technical: an overlay runs JavaScript after the page loads, while the real issues live in the page’s underlying code (missing labels, broken heading structure, menus that cannot be reached by keyboard). Fixing the code fixes it for everyone. A widget on top is, at best, a supplement.

What to fix first, in order

  1. Run a free automated scan, then read it skeptically. Tools like WAVE or Lighthouse catch the obvious problems (missing alt text, low contrast, unlabeled fields). Automated tools cannot catch everything, so treat a clean score as a starting point, not a verdict.
  2. Tab through your own site. Five minutes, no tools. Can you open the menu, submit the form, and close any popups with the keyboard alone?
  3. Fix contrast and labels. These are usually small code or style changes with a big effect.
  4. Write real alt text for images that carry meaning; leave decorative images with empty alt text.
  5. Check your forms and checkout, since those are where customers do business with you, and errors must be explained in text, not just by turning a field red.
  6. Publish an accessibility contact (an email or phone number) so someone who hits a barrier can tell you instead of calling a lawyer.

When the DIY route is fine, and when it is not

If you have a small brochure site on a modern theme, you can fix a lot of this yourself in an afternoon: contrast, alt text, labels, a keyboard pass. That is a genuinely reasonable first step and costs nothing but time.

It gets harder when the site is built on a page builder or a heavy template, when your store has custom checkout steps, or when popups, sliders and third-party widgets are involved. Those problems sit in code you did not write. This is one reason we hand-code our sites: clean, semantic markup is a much better base for accessibility than layers of builder output. We cover that trade-off in more detail in our web design process, and keeping a site healthy after launch is part of what our care plans cover. Accessibility is not a one-time fix, because every new page or plugin can introduce new problems.

What we will not tell you

We will not tell you that a certain tool, plugin or redesign makes you “ADA compliant” or immune from a lawsuit. Nobody honest can promise that. What you can do is reduce the real barriers on your site, document that you are working on them, and get qualified legal advice if you receive a demand letter.

Not sure where your site stands? Book a free 20-minute call and we will walk through your site with you, honestly, including what you can fix yourself. Book your free call.

ADA Website Compliance in Florida: What to Fix First

Keep reading

More insights.